Whatwhatringrang
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2022
- Messages
- 354
- Reaction score
- 470
ok, name that band... or name the guitar players? & the rest of the musicians...
Is that Paul? Mr. Big?
ok, name that band... or name the guitar players? & the rest of the musicians...
yep, he's one of the guitarists...Is that Paul? Mr. Big?
ok, name that band... or name the guitar players? & the rest of the musicians...
John Paul Jones is playing slide...I don’t know you got me . Drummer and bassist have a great pocket . Slick lap steel tone . Looks like he is playing a vintage modern or there is one back there. See some jcm900s
Get outta here lol .You know I was gonna say John Paul Jones . He still looks young and its cool to see him play/sit in with other bands over the years. From what I hear he is humble .Always one of my favorites of Zep.John Paul Jones is playing slide...
Paul Gilbert guitar
Nuno Bettencourt guitar
I'm not sure who bass is, I thought it was Alex Skolnick at 1st, but, playing bass, I doubt it. Not sure of the drummer either...
he did a benefit show last year:Get outta here lol .You know I was gonna say John Paul Jones . He still looks young and its cool to see him play/sit in with other bands over the years. From what I hear he is humble .Always one of my favorites of Zep.
ok, name that band... or name the guitar players? & the rest of the musicians...
Yeah, all songs (and bands) with great vocal harmonies. My band fooled around with a soul-ish version of "Walk Away Renee" that we may revive some time. I'm not a good singer and on the chorus all I had to do was sing every word hanging on the 5th. D if we did it in G, E if we did it in A. And the front vocalists who are massive and gifted talents did all the real work LOL. But that's a harmony arrangement trick that thickens things up considerably, when some of the individual voices do not follow every chord in the changes in relation to the other voices.So then you'd also be familiar with:
The Rain, The Park, and Other Things (I Love The Flower Girl)
Everyone Knows it's Wendy
Walk Away Renee
Cherish
On the vocals - yeah, I think those are one of my biggest attractions to some of those songs (any music, actually). The Mamas/Papas, a lot of them had... I don't know what it's called, but maybe "dissonant" notes?... notes where you wouldn't normally go, but they make the mood? You can throw in the Fifth Dimension too: "Aquarius" and "Beautiful Balloon", also some songs by the Beach Boys (who got their style from the Four Freshmen).Yeah, all songs (and bands) with great vocal harmonies. My band fooled around with a soul-ish version of "Walk Away Renee" that we may revive some time. I'm not a good singer and on the chorus all I had to do was sing every word hanging on the 5th. D if we did it in G, E if we did it in A. And the front vocalists who are massive and gifted talents did all the real work LOL. But that's a harmony arrangement trick that thickens things up considerably, when some of the individual voices do not follow every chord in the changes in relation to the other voices.
The Association had very cool layered harmonies in just about everything I ever heard them do. I'm familiar with the songs you mentioned but many bands ago I actually did a version of "Along Comes Mary" without vocal harmonies. One of the band members claimed that song was about smoking weed and eating pn55y.
On the vocals - yeah, I think those are one of my biggest attractions to some of those songs (any music, actually). The Mamas/Papas, a lot of them had... I don't know what it's called, but maybe "dissonant" notes?... notes where you wouldn't normally go, but they make the mood? You can throw in the Fifth Dimension too: "Aquarius" and "Beautiful Balloon", also some songs by the Beach Boys (who got their style from the Four Freshmen).
Here's a section I think is amazing. It's also an (poor) example of what I mean by "dissonance", in the low notes here, though I may be using the wrong word:
Listen to it couple of times, because you might not be used to the sound at first...
Very good analysis.Yeah, very cool! I don't think I would call it dissonance but I would call it close harmonies - which to me means harmonies that are closer than thirds + fifths like you typically hear. Instead there are for example notes one step away from another instead of strictly chord tones. To some people it can sound like it "clashes" but I have a pretty flexible idea of harmony so to me it sounds great!
The part of "Are you staying..." that totally makes the song is right in the opening, where the chords go from Eb - "Don't let a lonely..." - Ebmaj7+9 - "... Monday come a-" - Ab9 - "-gain" and right there, the middle voice is on the fourth and the highest voice is on the fifth - Bb, only a step away from the next lower voice. The three voices in the It's My Party version are low to high Eb - Ab - Bb and because of that close harmony it sounds way more dense.
I was not much into those guys and I can't relate any thoughts about their stuff beyond what was on the radio on a regular basis.Very good analysis.
Where else, thoughts on Gary Puckett & The Union Gap? Hamilton, Joe Frank & Reynolds? Not sure if you go that far, but seems like you know your way around pretty well.